Returns Guide

We want you to love your Sarah Cornwell Jewelry. If something isn't quite right, we're happy to help. 

Our Return Policy

We accept returns and exchanges within 30 days of delivery. Items must be unworn, in their original condition, and returned in their original packaging. Custom and personalized jewelry is not eligible for return.

Refunds are issued to the original form of payment, excluding original shipping charges.

Step One

Submit a return request

Login in to your SC Rewards account to submit a return request for eligible purchases. Don't have an account? Email support@sarahcornwelljewelry.com to initiate your return.

Step Two

Print your label

A label will be emailed to you to print for your return package.

gemstone earrings with silver teardrop accent in a white dish
Step Three

Pack it up

Items must be unworn, in their original condition, and securely packaged in their original packaging. 

Blue kyanite knotted gem necklace in a white dish
Engraved initial disc charm on a gold chain
Step Four

Drop it off

Address your package to:

Sarah Cornwell Jewelry – Returns
266 S. Main Street
Doylestown, PA 18901

Drop your package at your mailbox or nearest USPS drop site.

Need more assistance?

Returns & Exchanges FAQ

What is your holiday return policy?

Extended Holiday Returns

For purchases made between November 15 and December 24, 2026, we've extended our return window through January 30, 2027, to make holiday gifting a little easier.

  • Within 30 days of purchase: Eligible returns will be refunded to the original form of payment.
  • After 30 days of purchase, through January 30: Eligible returns will receive store credit.
What if I would like to make an exchange?

Items are eligible for exchange with 30 days of purchase. Contact our team at support@sarahcornwelljewelry.com for assistance with an exchange.

You will receive a shipping label to send back your item

Please package your jewelry securely in its original packaging and send to:

Sarah Cornwell Jewelry – Exchanges
266 S. Main Street
Doylestown, PA 18901

Original shipping charges are nonrefundable.

Does your jewelry have a warranty?

Yes, our pieces have a 30 day warranty for defects.

What if I want to return something outside of the 30 day window?

We understand that sometimes things don't work out as planned. While returns outside our 30-day window are not guaranteed, we're always happy to review your situation and see how we can help. Please reach out to us at support@sarahcornwelljewelry.com, and our team will be glad to discuss your options.